*

*
Paul Daugherty
Enquirer columnist files news and observations

Paul Daugherty
Paul Daugherty has been an Enquirer sports columnist since 1994 and has been chronicling Cincinnati sports since 1988. He has covered almost every major sporting event in America, as well as five Summer Olympics. Along the way, he has been named one of the country's top-5 sports columnists four times, and Ohio columnist of the year on seven different occasions. Last year, he was voted 2nd-best sports columnist in the country, by the Associated Press Sports Editors.

Powered by Blogger

Friday, July 06, 2007

Bonds and... free speech?

Got many calls on my 700 WLW Sports Talk show the last few days, from fans who said they were hassled and even ejected by vigilant Reds security people at GABP Tuesday and Thursday nights, for dogging Barry Bonds. They claimed guards told them not to use the word "steroids'' when heckling Bonds. I heard enough say the same thing to think it was at least believable.

I asked Reds security chief Kerry Rowland about it. He said there had been some sort of directive issued by MLB to that effect, but that if hecklers weren't profane, they could yell what they wanted at the Giants left fielder (Rowland also told me there were no armed FBI agents in the stands, then turned around and told an Enquirer reporter there were, so believe what you want.)

Point is: Who is Baseball to tell fans they can't dog Bonds? While you or I might find it sad/silly/ reprehensible, fans heckling athletes is about as rare as the sun rising in the East. As long as it's not profane or racial, what business does Baseball have telling people what they can yell at a ballgame?

It reminds me of what happened at Duke in the mid-80s. Coach K pleaded with the Cameron Crazies to stop the "Bullsh--'' chant after questionable refs calls. The next game, after a bad call, the Crazies chanted "We beg to differ, we beg to differ.''

Gag-ruling fans heckling Bonds? That's bullsh--, er, I beg to differ.


11 Comments:

at 10:29 AM Blogger Mr. Pitt said...

Paul,
I was at the game last night and found all of the rules absurd. Folks were not allowed walking in the aisles while Barry Bonds was at bat. I know that was in the best interest of fans and their view of a potential homerun but still a little odd.

I saw no signs, they may have been banned all together. Also, I saw security chatting with a group of guys attempting to start a "STEROIDS" and "CHEATER" chant. The guys stopped after security talked with them.

I find it very ironic that MLB has issued all of these rules for this record. However, the Commissioner isn't planning on attending the record breaking game or making a big deal about it. MLB doing things back asswards...imagine that?!?

 
at 2:58 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

I must completely agree that MLB making an attempt to gag fans is not only unnecessary, but borderline illegal. If security is suddenly dragging "fans" to the gate because they said something a specific player may find offensive, it tiptoes on the border of free speech rights.

Throwing objects onto the field, or even stepping onto the field itself, is a different situation. That then infringes upon safety of players/coaches/umpires. Doing something such as that could also interfere with the game.

To straddle the border even moreso, if one fan were to turn and yell at another anything that MLB finds offensive but is not illegal, must they also be carried to the parking lot?

 
at 3:34 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

I don't like Bonds. He cheated to be where he is. Even without the steroids he'd still probably be close to 600 (not over 700) home runs BUT the steroids cut the risk of muscle-ligament injury considerably, which means more playing time and therefore more home runs, hits, RBI, etc. It's not the added power as much as it is the longevity.

 
at 8:06 AM Anonymous Anonymous said...

Anon:
Whoah there!!! Your post is wrong in a primary FACT (a flawed fact that attempts to underscore your argument)...steroids DO NOT add to longevity, and they DO NOT "cut the risk of muscle-ligament injury considerably"...holy....I couldn't believe anyone would write that...I'm a former college athlete myself...wasn't anything awesome, but educated enough and around enough to know that steroids cause your muscles to get TOO STRONG for your ligaments, thus frequent injuries to steroid users in the area of ligament damage...the fact that Bonds has avoided a lot of the things most roid users experience means he's been a lucky exception, NOT the norm.

 
at 3:12 PM Blogger . said...

Hey Paul, love the blog!! Do you think it's possible that I could stay with you and your family for a few days? They're flea-bombing my apartment.

 
at 4:46 PM Blogger Frank Robinson's Ghost said...

The rules may be absurd, and MLB and the Reds may well be way off base in what they're trying to enforce.

But legally, there is no "free speech" issue. A baseball stadium is private property -- just like a theatre, and an MLB game is a private show -- just like a play. The stadium and the club are legally free to ban signs, chanting, or any kind of behavior they wish -- whether directed at players or at other fans. The First Amendment doesn't apply.

The only controls limiting what the club can do in that regard is the free market -- no one is forced to be there.

 
at 9:31 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

"Bonds hasn't been been convicted of anything" - innocent until proven guilty! Even politically-correct Junior says so (what's Jr. really believe?)
Why's Barry's head sooooo.. BIG?

 
at 4:23 AM Anonymous Anonymous said...

I agree... been working in the personal training field, as a certified personal trainer, and have seen many bodybuilders, and weight lifters overdue it and cause damage that has taken them out for weeks. You are stonger in a sence and more defined but the HUMAN body can not stand up to SUPER HUMAN strenght... none the less Bonds is approaching the most coveted milestone in baseball, and the sports writers in this country have magnified his substance abuse and chastised him for it beyond fair. Why arnt they callling for other sports stars to be tested... Clemens, Rice, Favre... the list goes on and on. Oh... even the Babe, isn't alcohol a drug? And doesn't drunken a-hole cast a negative light on baseball. This is about image right? No.. mabye it is entertainment... a game... mabye if we aproached other political issues with as much vigor as we do the "game" of baseball this country would be a better place to live.

 
at 1:47 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

I think that the REds and MLB are private businesses and they could ban Giants clothing of any kind from the ball park if they wanted to.

That said, Maybe if no one went to the games, people in management would notice. But with profit sharing, they could probably make a bundle if 1000 people showed up a game.

 
at 9:46 AM Anonymous Anonymous said...

To Frank Robinson's ghost ... some MLB stadiums are private property ... not this one. The Reds RENT it from Hamilton County. It's paid for by taxpayers. The Reds may or may not have the right to restrict speech under the terms of the lease agreement (without reading it, I don't know), but the stadium most definitely is not "private property." Should the Reds have the right to restrict speech at a facility paid for by taxpayer $$$? I'd love to hear someone make that argument.

 
at 9:32 AM Blogger Lou Elefante said...

Paul,
I'm a little late responding to this.......... anyway, personally I think MLB thinks that we're a bunch of fools, who over time will forget what went on for years. This stuff started back in the 80's in MLB (so says Canseco). Some people display their displeasure at games and Bonds is the target. Fair or unfair to Barry?, whatever. MLB was the enabler and has mishandled the situation for years. Selig should resign and MLB should admit to mishandling the situation and move on. It's not about Bonds, but he gets the brunt of it. If he only had 450 home runs, no one would give him the time of day. Did he unwittingly use steroids, the clear or cream?? Was Monica smoking a cigar, did Bill inhale, yadda, yadda, yadda. We're tired of being patronized by MLB. How about saying and doing the right things on behalf of our children, who look up to these athletes. Selig should be boo'd. My two cents.

 
Post a Comment*

* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.

By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site. << Home


Blogs
Jim Borgman
Today at the Forum
Paul Daugherty
Politics Extra
N. Ky. Politics
Pop culture review
Cincytainment
Who's News
Television
Roller Derby Diva
Art
CinStages Buzz....
The Foodie Report
cincyMOMS
Classical music
John Fay's Reds Insider
Bengals
High school sports
NCAA
UC Sports
CiN Weekly staff
Soundcheck