The Masters
When it comes to your job, most things you do because you have to. A few you do because you want to. A precious few are so memorable, you look forward to them all year. For me, that'd be covering the Masters.
Everything about the Masters slays me. I'm a sucker for tradition, sentiment and golf. I've got a fair amount of Southerner in me -- I had great-great-greats who fought against each other at Gettysburg --so all that bad poetry (some of it written by me) about the cathedral in the pines and the ghost of Bobby Jones makes perfect sense.
There is something about covering Jones' toon-a-mint that frees me from my normal cynicism. I can't explain it. Those of you who have been to the Masters will know what I'm talking about. It's the only event I'm ever sad to leave.
I've been fortunate to have covered 20 Masters. My first was in 1983, the second win of Seve Ballesteros. I saw Nicklaus win in '86, still the greatest sporting event I've witnessed in 30 years of doing this. I walked with Earl and Tida Woods in '95, Tiger's 1st year at Augusta, when he was an amateur. Nine holes, just me and his folks. Two years later, he went 18-under par, and golf would never be the same.
I've spent hours talking with Augusta's caddies, African-American gentlemen who know the course better than anyone, and whose stories could fill a vault the size of Amen Corner. I've heard the Roars, and over the years, come to interpret their sounds, each unique. There was a Nicklaus Roar in '86 and again a decade later, when he somehow challenged for the lead on Sunday afternoon. And there is a Tiger Roar, equal parts bemused fascination at how good he is and unabashed enthusiasm for his talents. The Roars roll up the hills from 11-12-13, Amen Corner, all the way to the clubhouse. You can almost cover the tournament by listening to it.
The Masters is an event where integrity matters, where tradition isn't bartered for cash and where a very good player almost always wins. For me, it's the perfect blend of drama, sportsmanship and romance. Nothing compares.
The paper isn't sending me this year. As strange as it sounds, I don't think I'll watch on TV. Too difficult. Tiger will win, of course. The course is soft, unlike last year, so the shorter hitters are in trouble. At Augusta, it's all about putting your tee ball in position to attack a very specific area on the green, to give yourself reasonable birdie tries. Tiger's length off the tee allows him to play a wedge or a 9-iron into most of the par-4s. Shorter hitters are trying to stick a 5- or 6-iron approach into an area of the green that might be only 8 or 10 feet square.
But strategy was never what the Masters was about for me. Strategy doesn't describe the way the sunlight looks and feels shafting through a loblolly pine at noon, or what the utter quiet of sunset sounds like, when you walk the course after the play is done for the day.
It's a magical place. I'll get back there again. Maybe next year...
44 Comments:
Okay, Paul, let's hear your answer to the big question: who's "The Greatest," Tiger or Jack?
And for me the more interesting question is how do you think they would stack up in each other's era in their primes (excluding, if you will, any sort of racial pressures Tiger might have faced).
Thanks for you thoughts.
Tiger, hands down. Better short game than Jack... though he might not have a Palmer or a Watson as a rival, Tiger also plays against better competition. Nicklaus was great. Tiger is better.
Hey Paul,
I couldn't agree more, there isn't any other event on Earth that can rouse child-like reverence and enthusiasm like walking Augusta. The azaleas, towering pines, hills and rolling greens that tv just can't capture no matter how good HD gets, and the immense respect every single player has for the course and the event makes it the purest contest in pro or college athletics. It is the only event that exceeds the hype around it every single year, no matter the outcome, for those who attend it.
My fiance's family scored a couple of passes to last year's opening round, and she knew how much I dreamed of going and gave them to me as a birthday gift. I called my dad, and he booked a flight that night and flew down the next day. We walked the course, stopping at the 15th green/16th tee for quite a while, and watched Tiger tee of on 18. Bob Costas once said that when he thinks of his father, the happiest moment they ever shared and the moment he'll always remember most fondly was the moment he and his father walked into Yankee Stadium and saw Mickey Mantle for the first time. Well, that's the way I feel about my father and Augusta; the moment we were both happiest and the moment I'll always remember most fondly is the first time the two of us stood next to the big scoreboard and looked across the first fairway to view the most breathtaking site either of our eyes have ever seen.
Paper isn't sending you? You could always "pay your own way".
ST CSA
Best VCR tape I ever recorded was last 9 holes in 1986 - WOW. Agree with you Paul that it simply doesn't get any better. As hard as it to admit, also agree that Tiger is better.
Enquirer went cheap on you??
Anything we bloggers could do for next year - like organize a campaign?? "Send Paul Daugherty to the Masters '09" rally?
We owe you, afterall.
Paul- Great thoughts, as usual. Just in case you missed one of the 10,783 promos that have run since December, ESPN is covering the early rounds starting tomorrow. I'm guessing you'll be pulled in to that television set way before Sunday afternoon.
Not to mention Tiger plays under a significantly greater microscope and deals with a lot more in terms of media.
Tiger will own the major championships record and PGA tour wins record by the time he turns 40, if it takes him that long. For me, the most impressive thing is he constantly is in the top 10. His game is razor sharp each week he tees it up. No question who the greatest is.
Paul, any thoughts of writing a book on Augusta's caddies? Could be a great read on their experiences relating to golf/history?
Paul, hopefully for when you go back next year, in downtown old Augusta there's a hole in the wall Italian restaurant. Don't know the name, but it's awesome. Just tell the cabbie and I'm sure they'll know. You'll have to wait for a table, but the sidewalk conversation with everyone else waiting is priceless. I also recommend the pool hall/bar right next door for a large fish bowl of beer while you're waiting for your table. Perhaps you've been there. Just another part of the overall Master's experience. Nothing else like it. Nothing.
Chris
Mason
I find it hard to revel in a tradition of sexism and racism. While I realize that private clubs have the right to determine membership any way they choose, we as a society (and the PGA) do not have to glorify institutions that are basically blackmailed into social inclusion.
There are some traditions worthy of celebration and some worthy of embarrassment. Sadly, even as a WASP, this is an example of the latter.
The Masters is the most pretentious sporting event in this country, by far.
JB
Hey, 940... organize a campaign, go door to door, sell cookies... or just write me a check for $1,000, give or take. After all these years of selfless entertainment I've provided, it really is the least you could do.
Doc-
I would love nothing more than to see Tiger and Phil tee off together on Sunday.
For any other Tiger fans, here is a link to a pretty cool Tiger video from a couple years back. A closest to the pin contest for a new Buick. Pretty good stuff. (Watch him tee of right handed with a left handed club.. amazing)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubAxWIfcE5I
Thanks
Oh, how soon we forget. On several fronts.
The Masters is an event where integrity matters? Yes, the integrity to not allow black players until 1975, 4 years after Bobby Jones died. That'd be nearly 30 years after Jackie Robinson broke baseball's color barrier. Or the golf club where a black man was not a member until 1990. Where women still are not members.
Or how about the integrity of the golf course? Bobby Jones would be more pissed about the wholesale changes made to his course than the fact that a black man was revered as the best player on his beloved course, which is saying something. Augusta used to be the US's version of St. Andrews - open and accessible to the eye, multiple ways to play it, various paths to the hole, but requiring precision as well as imagination. It's now just another heavily tree-lined behemoth. The options are gone, and the strategy that the course required is now lost.
Tiger plays against better competition? The worst players on the PGA tour in Tiger's era are better than the worst players on the Tour in Jack's era, but of the players at the top, the one's that really matter, there's no comparison. Vijay, Phil, Els, Sergio, Adam Scott, Davis Love, Goosen, David Duval, Furyk. Those are the probably the best that Tiger's played against in his career. Trevino, Arnie, Watson, Seve, Johnny Miller, Hale Irwin, Gary Player, Billy Casper, Ray Floyd, Fuzzy, this list goes on and on. I wouldn't pick any of Tiger's top competition over Jack's. Could you ever see Gary Player doing what Phil did at Winged Foot? Would Watson ever wither like Els does? And give Johnny Miller or Seve or Irwin in their primes an oversized trampoline for a driver and a golf ball that doesn't get side spin. Tiger would still be the best, but he wouldn't be running away with these things, and Jack's foes wouldn't hyperventilate when Tiger hit his first tee shot.
Tiger is a better chipper than Jack, but the premium was not on chipping the way it is now. Heck, he made everything from 10 feet in anyway, so he didn't really need to be a great chipper. Jack was an amazing putter and probably the best pressure putter ever. He also hit the ball longer than Tiger does, relative to the field. He was hitting 300 yard drives with persimmon and towering 2 irons with balatas. Tiger is amazing, but Jack did it against greats. Tiger and Jack would be a great match, but Jack in his prime was something else. And he didn't have to beat the Vijays and Sergios, he had to beat Trevino and Palmer. No comparison between competition.
U.S. Open > Masters.
11:59...
Very well said.
This comment has been removed by the author.
1159...good debate... I'd argue that golf is more of an international game now, that Tiger over the years has had to contend with better players from all over the world than Jack did. And some of the names you mentioned hardly strike fear...
Right on, 11:59.
Don't forget the easier travel (Tiger's had a jet for years), lighter schedule (Tiger doesn't have to play to pay the bills, he had $40 mil guaranteed from Nike when he started, nice cushion, ehh, and with the much bigger payouts on top of that, he is so stinkin' filty rich he can pick and choose events much more than the 70s guys so he's much fresher), less distractions (Jack and Barb had lots of kids around to feed and raise during his salad days), and the equipment...my Gawd the equipment. Tiger has his own club designer, his own branding, heck even his entire wardrobe is picked out before the year starts.Has there ever been a more pampered great in any sport in his early years?
And don't even get me started on the differences in tournament toughness between the players now and during Jack's prime. Guys like Couples, Love, Duval, Howell III, Garcia, even Ernie, none can hold a candle to all the guys Nicklaus consistently beat. The top tier was chock full of greats back then, not a bunch of pretenders. Jack won so many tournaments in a nose to nose duel to the end, he earned his nickname The Bear. Tiger is an unknown quantity to this day since guys like Mickelson and Garcia and Els self destruct and fall apart all the time. Duval is the ultimate self destruction story of all time in golf, or is it Daly???And these guys could have been good competiton for Tiger, if they weren't head cases.
Until Tiger shows me he can beat the next young great or greats, someone of extraordinary talent like Palmer, or Nicklauss, or Snead, or Hogan, or Woods, and trust me they'll be along soon enough, of which there are none right now, on a consistent basis under pressure with both playing extremely well, I'm reserving my opinion that he is the best. Frankly head to head with Jack in his prime, I think Tiger wilts more often than Jack wilts. Jack could block out the sun if he needed to, and why do you think Tiger idolized Jack growing up?
As for the tournament, it's the most beautiful spectacle on TV i've ever seen. But it should be, the course is treated like a museum, pampered and tweaked to the point of near perfection, not to mention the most exclusive and difficult to get on. ?The membership originally was a good ol southern boys club of imagined aristocracy and fine manners. As a former caddy myself at some of the venerable clubs here in town, there's nothing more boring than people who think they are better than others simply because they have more money. No, give me much humbler places like Glenview, Shaker, The Vineyard, Lassing Pointe, all the roosting ground for one and all who call themselves golfers.
No one's excluded or made to feel like they're in the presence of royalty, And that's the way I like MY golf.
Tiger may turn out to be considered the greatest. But not just yet.
Ryan
If you are embarrassed to be a WASP perhaps you should move to another country.
Oldtimer, you had me until you called Tiger an "unknown quantity.''
So...Ryan from Dayton/Chicago can make a perfectly respectful (nothing ad hominem, etc) post and be told to go piss up a rope -- but PD is monitoring this blog for civility/rationality...hmmm...
Whatever --- this event is amazing to watch. But it has a tainted tradition and PD's failure to mention that is conspicuous by its absence. [Maybe you should ask what the African-American caddies who you revere so much think about the traditions...maybe we would all be surprised...] To just start genuflecting to a tradition with serious issues...poor form.
I was lucky enough to have a friend with a couple of extra tickets to yesterday's practice round.
Augusta National is truly one of the great, if not the greatest, golf courses in the world.
We wore ourselves out walking all over that course, and had a great time despite the cool weather in the morning.
I'd love to go back for one of the tournament rounds someday, although that seems unlikely due to the ticket situation.
Paul,
Golf is much more international today, but what international competitor today is soooo good? I mean, is any one of them as good as Player or Seve were?
The field today is deeper than before. There are a lot of nice players today. But the top is what matters, and it's not nearly as good.
No, Fuzzy and Irwin and Casper may not strike fear, but neither do Els and Davis Love and Vijay. No one strikes fear today except Tiger. Phil gets the lead and people wait for a blowup. Watson got the lead and people turned off their TVs because the tournament was over.
I'd also like to see Tiger make a Sunday charge and win one from behind. He's the best front runner, probably better than Jack even, but he's never come from behind and he doesn't have nearly as many close calls as Jack. It seems like Tiger is always right there, even when he's playing poorly, but for as many Majors as Jack won, he came in second more times than that! He was just always knocking on the door.
Tiger's got a lot of time. Heck, he should just be entering his best days right now. But as of today, it's Jack all the way.
...can't stand these hypotherticals...who's the greatest? different eras...jack was good and tiger is good...leave it at that...babe ruth was good...aarron was good ...griffey is good...and doc knows for sure tiger will win...i guess the other golfers should just stay home...pundits said tiger was going to win last year also...
Jack Nicklaus had much tougher competition (I guess you could debate that) but you can not debate the fact that golf has become too easy with all the equipment 'improvements'. Golf is fast becoming like bowling NO integrity anymore.
ST CSA
A couple of things that can't be captured on TV about Augusta are how hilly the course is especially numbers ten and eighteen and also how wide the fairways are. Oh, and everything is green down to the food wrappers. Very cool.
253 is absolutely right. My apologies. Very busy moderating, sometimes things slip in that shouldnt. help me out. keep it civil and on point.
Yo, Mr P-Dawg, what I meant was
Tiger is an unknown quantity in terms of playing against other greats who know how to finish...i.e., win coming down the stretch. Remember, Nicklaus finished second a record number of times too. Trevino, Miller, Watson, Player, Palmer, all multiple major winners, all could beat Jack on a good day. Other than Ernie, there's nobody out there today that scares or even aggravates Tiger, except maybe the papparrazi. The current crop are such a bunch of pretenders to the crown. Mickelson blowing an Open by not hitting 3 wood on 18. Sergio folding on Sundays. Duval quitting at the top of his game. Faldo got old. Maybe Ky boy John Holmes might stare him down someday. He certainly doesn't intimidate.
Tiger needs a challenger who is young, fabulously talented, and equally cocky to demonstrate whether he still can win as he ages. Tiger's never been tested on that level, and we all know he can have a temper. That's what I wanna see. How he responds. And if he retires early or plays a curtailed schedule, we'll never know.
Plus Jack played here in Cincinnati a fair amount as an amateur. He's a local boy of sorts. I've rooted unabashedly for him and Gary Player for years. Needless to say, I'm a little biased.
OK Paul, out of respect to you, I removed my offensive post. I don't think that the original posts from Ryan from wherever and his alter ego, Mr Anonymous has any business on the blog either. Sorry.
ST CSA
The Ying-Yang >>
Always liked the story about how Nicklaus had to drive his station wagon to tournaments with the 3 kids in the back vs. Tiger cell-phoning his manager to get the GulfStream ready.
On the other hand, seems to me Tiger is just mentally tougher than rest of his super-pampered (but very talented) opponents. He just wants it more >> kinda like Jack.
Oldtimer, it's PDaug, no hypen please.
I think the book idea is superb! Go for it!
Paul, You jested at 11:16 about "all these years of selfless entertainment I've provided".
Just like to say we're all lucky to have your posts regarding sports, family, music, deck/Keystones, etc. Thanks for not leaving for bigger & better.
I'd chip in on the cookie sale for the "Daugherty to Masters, '09 Fund" but that's an awful lot of cookies.
...as heard on the radio today...The Masters ...a tradition of racism and sexism like none other...
I almost never agree with your analysis but the reason I read your stuff (blog especially) is because the enjoyment and appreciation you feel for sports in general is palpable when I'm reading what you write. Doc to August 2009? I'm in...
Stopint: OUTRAGEOUS! isn't it. LMAO.
Paul,
On behalf of all of my fellow posters, a big "YOU'RE WELCOME" for all the entertainment we've provided to you.
Of course, MY posts are ALWAYS full of thought and incredible analysis. It's everyone else's that are funny!
There must be a good story in there about how you wound up walking the course with Tiger's parents??
I wonder if Tiger loses if he'll get stupid drunk,stash some reefer in his pocket,and refuse to get out of the street in front of Augusta when ordered by police then say "@$*^ this white club" and be lead away in handcuffs...maybe Doc can write an apology piece in the Enquirer if that happens...
Hey Paul,
My fiance's mom scored two passes for me for tomorrow's round. Once again, my dad's driving down straight from work, catching a couple hours of sleep, then we'll leave the house around 4:30 or 5 and drive from Greenville, SC, down to Augusta. I'll send you a $1.50 pimiento cheese sandwich.
Tiger broke par (-1) today for the first time in 5 rounds. I think he's washed up. JK, but he's dug a pretty deep hole.
I so hope Steve F. Wins. That will teach those Gannet tightwads a lesson for not sending you this year. Could have also helped you to line up a guest or two for radio...so some blame to Cheap Cannel, too.
Agree with some that the Masters is an event put on by rich, white, racist men. However, if it was done just as well by rich, racist black men - it'd still be amazing.
No matter the source, it's one of the best.
* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.
By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site. << Home